• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
light magazine logo and tag

Light Magazine

Inspiring Faith For Everyday Life

Voice of the martyrs Jun 9, 23 - B
  • Arts
  • Community
  • Faith
  • Family
  • Leadership
  • Life
  • Mission
  • Jobs
    • Job Dashboard
    • Post a Job
  • Events
  • Directory
  • About Us

How far can we agree with Critical Race Theory?

June 18, 2021 by Jack Taylor Leave a Comment

Critical race theory

When anyone advocates against injustice, oppression or evil then followers of Jesus find plenty in Scripture to support this direction. Followers of Critical Race Theory are focused on eliminating oppression as evil. God identifies with the suffering and oppressed and calls us to right the wrongs. He calls us to advocate for the powerless and vulnerable. He calls out states and institutions who promote wrongs and immoral actions against people. So haw far can we agree with Critical Race Theology?

Importing other ideology on the back of terms like “intersectionality” “white privilege” “colour-blind racism” “internalized oppression” “lived experience” and “heteronormativity” take us in a direction further than we can walk.

Apologist, Neil Shenvi, points out that current influencers like Kimberle Crenshaw, Peggy McIntosh, Robin DiAngelo and Eduardo Bonilla-Silva are among those coining the phrases popping up on college campuses, in political discussions and in social media. They “share an ideology based on four central ideas: the social binary, oppression through ideology, lived experience, and social justice.”

The idea that “society can be divided into dominant, oppressor groups and subordinate, oppressed groups along lines of race, class, gender, sexuality, and a host of other factors” is what Shenvi calls the social binary. Oziem Sensoy and Robin DiAngelo, in their book Is Everyone Really Equal, say that “for every social group, there is an opposite group… the primary groups that we name here are: race, class, gender, sexuality, ability, status/exceptionality, religion and nationality.” Consequently, “sexism, racism, classism, and heterosexism are specific forms of oppression.”

Shenvi points out that in their book [in a chart listed as 5.1] they have three columns with the type of oppression, the oppressor and the oppressed. For racism, whites are considered as oppressors and people of colour as oppressed. For sexism, (cis) men are oppressors and women, transgender and genderqueer are oppressed. For Heterosexism, heterosexuals are oppressors and gays, lesbians, bisexuals, two spirit, are oppressed. For religious oppression, Christians are oppressors and Muslims, Buddhists, Jews, Hindus, and other non-Christian groups are oppressed. Under ableism, able-bodied people are oppressors and people with disabilities are oppressed. Under colonialism, white settlers are oppressors and indigenous peoples are oppressed. 

When you add the idea of intersectionality (where a person has several categories of oppression combining to identify them) there is a strong chance for a victim mentality to embed itself. Scripture sees us all equally under sin and its consequences, regardless of race, social status, faith, or gender. That brokenness will be displayed in a wide diversity of injustices and wrongs.  The authors of this chart say that the empowered groups maintain their control by imposing their ideology on everyone. Thus, the Judaeo-Christian ideology of white European power was foisted onto indigenous peoples and others primarily by men wanting to maintain their sense of control in the world. A minority of “old white men” are thus still controlling our society.

Shenvi quotes Iris Young when she writes, “In its new usage, oppression designates the disadvantage and injustice some people suffer not because tyrannical power coerces them, but because of the everyday practices of a well-intentioned liberal society… Its causes are embedded in unquestioned norms, habits, and symbols.” Through the process of lived experience the oppressed are encouraged to trust and “give authority” to senses, feelings, and experiences regardless of what others might say is universal reality. Through conscious and subconscious reasonings the privileged prove that they are blinded by their privilege.

Critical Theory is finally founded on the pillar of social justice which is defined as “’the elimination of all forms of social oppression’ whether it’s based on ‘gender, race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, physical or mental ability, or economic class.” Practitioners of CRT see their primary moral duty is liberating groups from oppression. 

The Biden administration, in April, proposed to fund education programs informed by CRT with exemplary materials in K-12. CRT theorist Ibram X. Kendi wants a created ‘anti-racism’ department to have veto power over municipal, state and federal laws if there is any perceived disparity between groups and this veto power would extend to include candidates for political office. Kendi is said to believe that every action, thought, idea and policy is either ‘racist’ or ‘anti-racist.”

On a podcast with Sean MacDowell, Ghanian-Canadian, Samuel Sey, dealt with the issue of “how can we be critical of unbiblical ideas embedded in CRT yet not dismiss it wholesale and lack compassion for those who are hurting?” He says “Jesus Christ is the most gentle, patient, loving person who has ever walked the earth and yet he is the most offensive person that has ever walked the earth because of what he said… because of the truth. Biblical truth will offend people.” He sees CRT as a sinful response to the sinful ideology of white supremacy. He says “rejecting CRT is not the same as rejecting black people.” He does not believe there is any valid evidence for the existence of systemic racism any longer. There are unjust and unwise laws but that isn’t the same.

Sey’s biggest concern is that he sees CRT infiltrating Christian schools and universities. “Many schools have fully embraced it…it’s that bad. I’m deeply concerned by it. He says “God has already given you what you need to do [to love black people]. It’s in the Bible… God knows black people better than anyone else. God created black people. God is a God of justice. A God of love. You cannot love someone more than God… to love your neighbour as yourself because you love God. But you are not to show partiality for black people.”

About Jack Taylor

Jack TaylorJack Taylor (PhD) is an award-winning author, journalist and story teller who served 18 years in Kenya and 26 years in pastoral work in Vancouver. His One-Heart Coaching provides marriage support for leaders and draws on his 46 years of marriage to Gayle, special training, and his years in leadership. His youtube series, Imagine Easter and Imagine Christmas provide biblical insight. He is a founder of New Hope Community Services providing housing for refugees. For some of his 15 books see jackataylor.com. Jack is a regular contributor to Light Magazine.

View all posts by Jack Taylor | Website

Filed Under: Community Tagged With: Critical Race Theory

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Jack Taylor Salome 360 240 Jun 29 23 S
Pacific Academy Jun 26, 23 S
CFI web ad Jun 26, 23 S
Taylormotive Jun 26, 23 S
Better books and bibles 360 x 360 web ad sep 18 23
Intercede Jun 26, 23 - S
Visionvest Jun 26 23 S
Alistair Young sep 11 23 - S
CSB August 1 23 S
Ed Hird 360 x 240 Jun 29 23 S

Secondary Sidebar

Upcoming Events

Sep 14
September 14 @ 8:00 am - November 30 @ 5:00 pm

White Rock, BC: A Seven Week Living Bible Camp

Sep 28
September 28 @ 7:30 pm - October 21 @ 8:00 pm

Vancouver, BC: Empire of the Son at Pacific Theatre

Sep 29
September 29 @ 8:00 am - October 6 @ 5:00 pm

Israel & Online: Feast of Tabernacles – King of all the Earth

Sep 30
7:30 pm - 9:30 pm

Vancouver, BC: Dixit Dominus HWV 232, Georg Friedrich Händel

Sep 30
8:00 pm - 10:00 pm

Langley, BC: Very Very Improv at Bez Arts Hub

View Calendar

Recent Jobs

  • Part-Time Music Teacher (0.2 FTE)

    • Mission, BC
    • Valley Christian School
    • Part Time
  • Atlantic Canada Regional Representative

    • Work from home in NB or NS
    • Mennonite Central Committee Canada
    • Full Time
  • Donor Engagement & Resource Development

    • Burnaby, BC
    • Journey Home Community
    • Full Time
  • Senior Manager: Housing Resources & Partnerships

    • Burnaby, BC
    • Journey Home Community
    • Full Time
  • Senior Portfolio Manager, Fixed Income 

    • Langley, BC
    • Capstone Asset Management
    • Full Time

Directory

Businesses
141
Ministries
617
Schools
209

Articles Archive

Copyright © 2023 · Light Magazine · Website by Shannon Stange · Log in

Change Location
Find awesome listings near you!